ClipRoute

Free clipping guides and courses: Clip Kit, Campaign Filter, Launch Protocol, Edit Standard, Retainer Route, Campaign Radar, AI Clipping...
Bacău, RO
•
•Created byProfile pictureCristian Chitimus
70 joined
Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·5h

Posted the same morning: one Short hit 2,272 views, the other got 10.


Yesterday two Shorts went out within 30 minutes of each other, on two different channels. Same workflow, same checks, both around 15 seconds.


The numbers this morning:

• Channel A: 2,272 views in about 21 hours, 97% from the Shorts feed, and still climbing about 74 views an hour

• Channel B: 10 views in about 23 hours. Public, no warnings, the copyright check was clean. The feed tried it on a handful of people and moved on.


So today the two channels do opposite things:

• Channel A posts nothing. Its clip is still rising, and a new upload would pull the feed away from it.

• Channel B posts its next clip at noon. A clip with 10 views has nothing to protect.


The lesson I keep relearning: a hit happens at the level of one clip, not the format. Channel B has had clips on this exact recipe do 3,200 views and others do 4. That's why I don't change the recipe after one flop. I only change it when the same pattern shows up across several clips from the same period.


Channel A's next clip waits until its curve flattens.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·1d

Same week, three channels: 2,436 views, 212 views, 0 views.


Three Shorts went out within two days of each other, on three different channels. Same workflow, same checks before posting.


The numbers four days later:

• Channel A (two months old, clipping history): 2,436 views, 94% from the Shorts feed, approved in its campaign

• Channel B (created this week): 212 views, 95% from the feed, then it stopped

• Channel C (created this week): 0 views after 60 hours. Public, no claims, no warnings. YouTube simply never showed it to anyone.


Channel C's clip wasn't worse than the others. A brand-new channel just has no signal yet, and the first uploads are where it gets one.


What I'm doing about it:

• I don't judge a format from a new channel's first clips. Each one gets five posts before any verdict.

• A clip with zero views doesn't hold the next one back. There's nothing to cannibalize.

• Every clip gets re-read at 6 hours and 48 hours, so "it flopped" is a number, not a feeling.


Channel A posted its next clip this morning.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·4d

I posted 0 Shorts today. Yesterday's two are still growing 15 and 32 views an hour.


Today's posting slot came and I uploaded nothing, on purpose. Both channels have a clip ready, but yesterday's Shorts haven't stopped climbing.


The numbers this morning:

  • Channel A: 2,089 views in about 21 hours, still +32 views an hour, 95.5% of the early views from the Shorts feed

  • Channel B: 262 views in about 20 hours, still +15 views an hour, but almost all of it from YouTube search, not the feed


My rule is simple: if the last Short on a channel still grows 10+ views an hour, the next one waits. I've watched a new upload pull the feed away from a clip that was still rising, and the new one rarely makes up for it.


What I'm learning from Channel B: a Short can live on search alone. It's slow, but it keeps going after the feed has moved on. Titles with the show and character names are doing that work.


Both clips get re-read tonight. The ready ones go out as soon as the curve flattens.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·5d

5 Shorts over 17 seconds: median 61 views. 11 under 15 seconds: 1,209.


I went back through two months of Shorts on one of my clipping channels and split them by length. Same channel, same niche, same posting window.


The numbers:

  • 11 Shorts between 12 and 14 seconds: median 1,209 views

  • 4 Shorts between 16.3 and 16.8 seconds: all between 1,058 and 1,242

  • 5 Shorts of 17 seconds or longer: median 61 views (best one 345)


That's a big gap, but I'm treating it as a hypothesis, not a rule. Five clips is a small sample, and the longer ones may also have been weaker moments. Length and content are tangled together.


What I'm doing about it:

  • new windows on that channel stay at 16.8 seconds or less by default

  • I'll only call it confirmed after six clips over 17 seconds from the same period

  • every clip gets read at 6 hours, so the comparison stays honest


Today's campaign clip is 18.6 seconds, so it's the next data point either way.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·6d

Same recipe, four Shorts: 3.2K, 4, 2.3K, 4 views.


I made four Shorts on the same channel with the exact same recipe: one 11-15 second moment, the character's face in the first frame, one meme line on screen, posted at the same hour.


The results:

  • Short 1: 3.2K views

  • Short 2: 4 views

  • Short 3: 2.3K views

  • Short 4: 4 views


Same format, same length, same time slot. So the format isn't what decides it. The hit happens at the level of the single clip.


What the numbers do show is retention. The 3.2K Short kept 66.4% of viewers watching. The 2.3K one kept 32.6% and stalled after about two days. The two duds never got a test audience at all, they sat on "Other YouTube features" with zero feed views.


My rules now:

  • don't judge a format from fewer than 3 clips

  • don't post the next clip while the last one still grows 10+ views an hour

  • track "stayed to watch" on every clip, it's the number that explains the winners


Today's clip goes out at noon. I'll read it at 6 hours.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·Nov 14

The feed stopped pushing my Short. Search kept it going.


My last Short is 3 days old and sits at 2.2K views. In the last 48 hours it got 371 more:

  • Shorts feed: 189

  • YouTube search: 177


The feed push is over. Now almost half the views come from YouTube search.


That's why my titles open with the character's name, and the hashtags and description name the show and the episode. The feed gives you the spike. Search gives you the tail.


This one has gone flat, so the next clip is scheduled for tomorrow at 12:01.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·Nov 13

The feed pushed both Shorts. Retention decided which one kept going.

Two Shorts from the same series on my small channel, both picked up by the feed (83-90% of views from the Shorts feed):

  • Short A: 66% stayed to watch, 3.2K views, kept growing for 5 days

  • Short B: 33% stayed to watch, 2.1K views, slowed down after day 2


The feed gives every Short a first test. What happens after depends on how many people stay. I don't know yet exactly why B lost half its viewers. My first suspect is the opening: A starts on a line, B starts on a laugh.


Check this on your own clips: Analytics > Overview > "Stayed to watch". If it's under 40%, look at your first 2 seconds before you change anything else.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·Nov 11

Same recipe, two Shorts: 0 views, then 312 in 2 hours.

Monday's Short got 0 views in 48 hours. No claim problem, no restriction: the feed just never showed it.

Today's Short, same format and same kind of top line, had 312 views two hours after going live, 90% of them from the Shorts feed.


If I had judged the format on Monday's zero, I would have stopped. One clip is a sample of one.


What I do now:

  • one Short a day, made the day before and scheduled for the same hour

  • check feed % at a few hours and at 24 h, not just views

  • judge the format on 7-10 clips, never on a single one


Zeros happen. Consistency is what gets you enough tests for the good ones to show up.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·Nov 10

10 Shorts in 14 days on a small channel: 1 hit, 9 duds. The scoreboard.

I ran a test: one Short from the same animated series, same format, one at a time. The question was simple: does the Shorts feed pick up a small channel at all?


  • clips 1-8: 0-3% of views from the feed, 18 to 510 views each, almost all from search

  • clip 9: 90% from the feed, 1.5K in 7 hours, 3.2K now, 66% stayed to watch

  • clip 10, same recipe as 9: 0 views after 24 hours


So yes, the feed tests small channels. But one recipe doesn't guarantee the next clip a test. One hit in ten is a starting point, not a system.


What the hit had that the duds didn't: the top line was the character's own logic instead of a summary, the first frame showed the thing the line was about, and it ended right on the punchline.


If you're testing a format: log feed % at 24 h for every clip. Views alone hide whether the feed even tried.

Profile picture
Cristian ChitimusProfile picture@cristianchitimus·Nov 9

My winning Short went flat. So today the next one went up.

Last week I held a finished clip for 5 days, because the Short before it was still climbing. Here's the curve, one reading per morning:

  • day 2: 2,433

  • day 3: 2,732 (+299)

  • day 4: 3,044 (+312)

  • day 5: 3,179 (+135)

  • day 6: 3,207 (+28)


+28 in a day is flat. The feed has finished testing it, so the next clip can't steal its audience anymore.


The new one keeps the same recipe as the winner: the top line is the character's own logic, not a summary; the first frame shows faces; it ends on the punchline word. One thing I'll read at 24 h: how much of the traffic comes from the Shorts feed. The winner had 90% in its first hours.


If your best clip is still growing, wait. Post the next one when the daily gain drops close to zero.