The scaphoid fracture nobody talks about in fellowship
Every hand surgery fellow has seen the classic scaphoid waist fracture. Cast vs. percutaneous screw — straightforward decision tree.
But what about the proximal pole fracture with questionable vascularity in a 28-year-old rock climber who needs to be back on the wall in 3 months? Or the scaphoid nonunion with DISI deformity that's been missed for 2 years?
These are the cases that separate a fellow who "knows hand" from one who actually manages hand trauma.
Here's how I think through it:
1. Vascularity first. MRI with gadolinium before any fixation decision. If the proximal pole is avascular, you're looking at a vascularized bone graft (1,2-ICSRA pedicled graft) — not just a headless screw and a prayer.
2. DISI means the carpus has already adapted. You can't just bone graft and fixate. You need to correct the dorsal intercalated segment instability first, or your construct will fail under load.
3. Return-to-activity is a contract, not a timeline. I tell patients: "I'll tell you when the bone is healed. You tell me when the function is back." CT at 8 weeks, grip strength testing at 12.
This is the kind of structured, case-based thinking I built The Trauma Hand around — fractures, dislocations, tendon injuries, and complex reconstructions organized the way we actually reason through cases in the OR.
If you're a hand surgery fellow who wants a trauma reference that doesn't read like a textbook, check it out.
