Why your restaurant's Instagram is dying (and it's not the algorithm)
Ran content for a dozen local brands this year — cafés, streetwear, gyms. Same mistake every time: they post like a press release. "Excited to announce our new menu item 🎉" gets 40 views. A blurry video of the cook arguing with a customer about pineapple on pizza gets 40,000.
The algorithm isn't punishing you. Your content just isn't content — it's an ad wearing a caption. People don't follow brands, they follow personalities. Wendy's isn't a fast food account, it's a comedian who happens to sell fries.
Three things that actually move the needle for small consumer brands:
Comments are content. Screenshot your weirdest DM or comment and turn it into a post. Free, authentic, and it makes your audience feel like they're part of an inside joke.
Recurring bits > one-off posts. Pick a joke, a rivalry, a mascot, a running gag — and repeat it weekly. Repetition is what makes an account feel like "a thing" instead of a feed.
Lower the production value on purpose. A phone video shot in 20 seconds outperforms a $500 shoot almost every time right now. Polish reads as "trying to sell me something."
We built Menace Media Co. around this exact idea — treating brand accounts like internet personalities instead of catalogs. If you run a local brand and your content feels stuck in 2019, happy to trade notes.
