One SPX Weekly Trade, Start to Finish: How a Trade Changes Along the Way
Whop is the online community where SOS members get trade alerts and updates. You can see the membership options and join here: *whop.com/simple-option-strategies*
Most trade results you see are just a final number. That number hides most of what actually happens in a trade. So we're doing something different: we're picking one SPX Weekly trade and following it through its whole life, from the day it's opened until it's fully closed.
In this issue, we walk through that trade step by step: how it was opened, what changed, and where it stood at our last check. Every number has a date on it, so you can always tell what was already locked in and what was still open. You don't need any background to follow along. We'll explain each step as we go.
First, what this trade is
This trade has two sides, a put spread and a call spread. They aren't two separate trades. They're two halves of one SPX Weekly trade, and they get judged together.
The put side carries the risk if SPX falls.
The call side carries the risk if SPX rises.
We get paid a credit up front to open both sides. But that credit is not locked-in profit. It's money collected for taking on risk, and how much of it we keep depends on how each side is closed or how it expires.
Oct. 26 - Opening the trade
Both spreads expire Nov. 25, 2026.
Put side: sold 10 of the 7325/7300 put spreads at $2.85 credit each ($2,850)
Call side: sold 10 of the 8000/8025 call spreads at $2.95 credit each ($2,950)
Total opening credit: $5,800 before fees
At this point, nothing is realized. The trade is open on both sides.
Nov. 5 - The original calls are closed
We bought back all 10 of the original 8000/8025 call spreads at $0.45 each. We sold them for $2.95 and bought them back for $0.45, which is $2.50 per spread.
That locked in a $2,471.20 gain on the call side, after fees. This piece is final. It can't change from here.
The original 7325/7300 put spreads stayed open. For the moment, the trade had only put-side risk.
Nov. 6 - A new call side is opened
The next day, in a separate transaction, we sold 10 of the 7735/7760 call spreads, also expiring Nov. 25, at $3.05 credit each ($3,050 before fees).
This brought call-side risk back into the trade, but at new strikes. The new spread sits at 7735/7760, below the original 8000/8025. So the trade was back to having two sides: the original puts, plus a different set of calls.
Nov. 11 - How can one side be up while the trade is down?
This is the part that surprises a lot of newer traders.
At 3:20 p.m. ET on Nov. 11, the two spreads still open (the original puts and the new calls, 10 of each) showed a combined loss of $3,328.80 at the market midpoint.
We still had the $2,471.20 gain from the original calls. But the loss on the open spreads was bigger than that gain:
Realized gain, original calls (Nov. 5): +$2,471.20
Open spreads at midpoint (Nov. 11, 3:20 p.m. ET): -$3,328.80
Full trade, including fees paid to that point: -$857.60
So yes, the call side had a real, locked-in gain, and the trade as a whole was still down. Both things are true at once. That's why we judge the trade as a whole, not one side at a time.
This was a dated estimate, not a final result
The Nov. 11 figure is a snapshot taken at one moment, using midpoint prices. Those prices move all day. The remaining puts and calls were still open, and the final result will depend on how they're actually closed or how they expire.
We'll report the final result once the remaining positions are resolved.









